(Category) (Category) Isuzu 4x4 Frequently Asked Questions : (Category) Engine Performance : (Category) Forced Induction :
Turbo vs Supercharging
Moderator: houlster@inficad.com (inherited from parent)
The turbo vs supercharger debate is a never ending discussion among enthusiasts. Which one is "best" depends entirely on the vehicle, engine and what you use it for.

There are 3 main categories:

******* Turbocharger: *******

A turbo is an exhaust drive turbine, connected through a shaft to a centrifugal compressor that forces air into the intake manifold. Being driven by exhaust gasses, the boost it produces is directly related to the load on the engine. The more load, the more exhaust pressure and the more boost you get.

You can have a small, light turbo car that takes 5000 rpm and (Xref) WOT before you see significant boost. You can also have a big, 5000 lb truck pulling an 8000 lb trailer up a hill with a big V-8 pushing 20 pounds of boost at only 1800 rpm.

There's no doubt that a turbo can give huge amounts of boost from relatively small packages, but there is a distinct lag between the throttle and when the boost kicks in. This lag is highly dependant on a multitude of things that determine how well the turbo is matched to the vehicle, engine and it's application. Installation is generally a bit complicated too as it has to be plumbed into the exhaust system and have oil and usually water lines connected as well.

A turbo works well with lighter vehicles where turbo lag isn't as noticible, or heavier vehicles that pull heavy loads where maximum power and efficiency is more important than throttle response. Boost levels up to 30 psi and more can pretty easily be had with a turbo, but it takes a tremendous amount of engine work and system design to get and handle this much boost.


******* Positive Displacement Supercharger: *******

A positive displacement supercharger will generally be much bigger than an equivalent boost turbo and can usually give only moderate boost of around 10 - 15 psi max. It's major advantage is that boost is directly related to throttle position and can give instant throttle response. There is no lag, and boost is pretty much determined by throttle position without regard to rpm or load.

This is a good option for most street vehicles, especially those with smaller engines. It gives the best power increases throughout the rpm band, and it is very consistant. It's the one option that will feel most like having a bigger, torquier engine without surges, or lag. If you're running around 7 or 8 psi of boost, it will feel like you have half again the engine that you do at any rpm, speed and/or throttle setting.


******* Centrifugal Supercharger: *******

Like the Positive Displacement SC, this type of SC is belt driven from the crank and boost is dependant on engine rpm. But, like a turbo, it makes this boost with a centrifugal fan.

Boost with a Centrifugal SC is not linear. It produces next to nothing at lower rpm's, builds slowly as rpm's come up, then faster and reaches max boost quickly towards engine redline.

This is due in part by the centrifugal compressor. The flow it produces increases with the square of the velocity with which it's turning. You could gear it so you get max boost at 3000 engine rpm, but that means that a 6000 rpm, you'd have 4 times as much boost. A compromise is sometimes taken, where max boost is set at around 80% or so of engine redline, and a blow-off or bypass valve opens above this point to keep boost from going higher when you cross this rpm value.

Centrifugal SC's work best with vehicles that have bigger engines with lots of torque (like a (Xref) SBC with an "RV" cam), but quickly run out of steam at higher rpms where they don't breathe so well. As rpms come up and (Xref) VE starts to drop drastically, the boost from the SC is coming up and quickly makes up the difference to keep it pulling hard all the way to redline. Being a centrifugal compressor, they can, like the turbo, be set up to produce huge amounts of boost.


*********************

Finally, there are so-called "experts" out there everywhere with their opinions on what's best (including me :) The best thing to do is search high and low to get various opinions, pros and cons. There are some good books out there, and the 'net especially has a lot of good info once you learn to weed out the armchair quarterbacks from those with experience. Judge what you read by it's source. Is it some guy typing something he read once, or is it someone that has been playing with boost for a couple years and has some first-hand experience? Is it someone with who's done this with the same vehicle/engine you're considering, or someone with an entirely different engine or application? Weigh carefully what you read, or what those you talk to say and draw your own conclusions. At the very least, this will help you decide which way to proceed when starting out.


houlster@inficad.com

Subcategories:

Answers in this category:

[Add a New Answer in "Turbo vs Supercharging"]
This document is: http://ifaq.houlster.com/cgi-bin/isuzu-faq?file=131
[Search] [Appearance] [Show This Entire Category]
This is a Faq-O-Matic 2.711.
This FAQ administered by houlster@inficad.com